Independent journalism from St. Vincent and the GrenadinesSupport VPNNewsletterAdvertiseYouTubeContact
VINCYPOWA NEWSPower to the People

Independent journalism from St. Vincent and the Grenadines, for the Caribbean and the world.

,

Stuart Young Secures Hilaire Settlement as SVG Election Petitions Continue

VINCYPOWA News editorial graphic of Stuart Young SC with the headline Stuart Young Secures Hilaire Settlement, dated November 2, 2026.

The Hilaire settlement, reached before trial in Trinidad and Tobago, brings renewed attention to former Prime Minister and Senior Counsel Stuart Young, who leads the legal challenge to the parliamentary eligibility of SVG Prime Minister Godwin Friday and Foreign Affairs Minister Fitzgerald Bramble.

Former Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister and Senior Counsel Stuart Young has helped secure the Hilaire settlement, bringing the former Central Bank governor’s legal challenge to a close before trial. Dr. Alvin Hilaire had challenged his June 2025 dismissal by the Trinidad and Tobago government.

The development is particularly noteworthy for St. Vincent and the Grenadines, where Young is the lead attorney representing Carlos Williams and Luke Browne in the ongoing election petitions challenging the parliamentary eligibility of Prime Minister Dr. Godwin Friday and Foreign Affairs Minister Dwight Fitzgerald Bramble.

According to a November 2 report by the Trinidad and Tobago Guardian, the State approached Hilaire with a settlement proposal shortly before the trial was scheduled to begin at the Port-of-Spain High Court.

Following discussions, the parties reached an agreement reportedly favorable to the former Central Bank governor. The financial terms of the settlement have not been publicly disclosed.

Hilaire Settlement Ends Legal Dispute Before Trial

Hilaire’s legal challenge arose from the Trinidad and Tobago Cabinet’s June 24, 2025 decision to recommend the termination of his appointment as governor of the country’s Central Bank. The government subsequently appointed former Finance Minister Larry Howai to replace him.

Hilaire challenged the circumstances surrounding his removal and sought legal declarations and compensation for alleged violations of his rights.

Earlier reporting indicated that he was seeking approximately TT$9.8 million, including compensation associated with the premature termination of his appointment. However, that figure represented his legal claim. It should not be confused with the undisclosed amount agreed upon in the settlement.

The case had been scheduled for trial on November 2, with testimony expected from Hilaire and government minister Kennedy Swaratsingh. Instead, the parties reached an agreement before the trial commenced.

Young represented Hilaire alongside attorneys Anthony Bullock and Imran Ali.

Although the agreement represents a significant outcome for Hilaire, the settlement does not establish that a court found his dismissal unconstitutional or unlawful. The dispute was resolved through agreement rather than a final judicial determination of the allegations.

The Same Attorney Leading SVG’s Election Petitions

Young’s involvement in the Hilaire case has attracted additional attention because of his leading role in one of the most consequential constitutional election disputes in St. Vincent and the Grenadines.

Following the November 27, 2025 general election, unsuccessful Unity Labour Party candidates Carlos Williams and Luke Browne filed petitions challenging the eligibility of Friday and Bramble to serve as elected members of Parliament.

Williams is challenging Friday’s election in the Northern Grenadines, while Browne is challenging Bramble’s election in East Kingstown.

VINCYPOWA News illustration of the SVG flag, scales of justice and the headline SVG Election Petitions Await High Court Ruling.
VINCYPOWA News conceptual illustration. The courthouse imagery is illustrative; it is not a documentary photograph of the court.

The petitions center on the respondents’ Canadian citizenship and the interpretation of Section 26(1)(a) of the Constitution of St. Vincent and the Grenadines.

That provision concerns disqualification from parliamentary membership where a person is, through their own actions, under an acknowledgment of allegiance, obedience or adherence to a foreign power or state. The petitions also raise questions under Section 35 of the Representation of the People Act.

Young leads the petitioners’ legal team, while former Trinidad and Tobago Attorney General Anand Ramlogan SC leads the legal team representing Friday and Bramble.

Both respondents have acknowledged acquiring Canadian citizenship, but their attorneys maintain that holding Canadian citizenship does not disqualify them from serving in Parliament under the constitutional framework applicable to Commonwealth citizens. The petitioners dispute that interpretation.

The constitutional questions remain before the High Court, presided over by Justice Gertel Thom. For background, see VINCYPOWA News’ September report on the dual-citizenship evidence and competing legal arguments.

Hilaire Settlement and SVG Petitions Raise Different Legal Questions

The two proceedings demonstrate Young’s continued involvement in high-profile Caribbean litigation following his tenure as Prime Minister of Trinidad and Tobago.

In Trinidad, the dispute concerned the government’s decision to remove a senior public official from office and the legality of that decision. In St. Vincent and the Grenadines, the court is being asked to interpret constitutional qualifications for parliamentary membership and determine their application to two elected officials who also possess Canadian citizenship.

The distinction is fundamental. A negotiated settlement in the Hilaire matter does not establish a precedent determining how the Vincentian court must interpret its Constitution. Nor does it provide any legal indication that the petitioners in SVG will necessarily succeed.

Nevertheless, the settlement adds another significant development to Young’s legal career at a time when Vincentians are closely following his arguments in the election petitions.

Constitutional Questions Remain Unanswered in SVG

The Vincentian proceedings have already brought important constitutional issues into public debate. Among them are whether voluntarily acquiring Canadian citizenship constitutes acknowledgment of allegiance to a foreign state for the purposes of Section 26(1)(a), how the Constitution treats Commonwealth citizenship, and whether the relevant electoral legislation affects the eligibility of the respondents.

The petitions have implications extending beyond Friday and Bramble. The eventual judgment could clarify the interpretation of parliamentary eligibility provisions and influence future electoral disputes involving dual citizenship.

Until the High Court delivers its ruling, however, the legal positions advanced by both sides remain arguments for judicial determination.

A Settlement in Trinidad, a Judgment Awaited in SVG

The Hilaire settlement of November 2 brings an end to a legal dispute that had attracted substantial public attention in Trinidad and Tobago. For Stuart Young, it represents a consequential negotiated resolution in a case involving the dismissal of a senior public official.

For St. Vincent and the Grenadines, attention now returns to a separate constitutional contest in which Young represents the petitioners challenging the eligibility of two senior government figures.

The settlement in Trinidad may strengthen public perceptions of Young’s effectiveness as an attorney, but it is not evidence of how Justice Thom will rule.

Ultimately, the Friday–Bramble petitions will be decided on the Vincentian Constitution, the applicable law, the evidence, and the arguments presented before the High Court—not on the outcome of an unrelated case in Trinidad and Tobago.

Sources and Further Reading

Vincypowa News is independent and self-funded. We apply the same scrutiny to every government. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it. Our standards

Get the VPN Morning Brief

The day’s most important SVG and Caribbean stories, free in your inbox before work.

Support independent journalism

Vincypowa News is self-funded, with no party, government or corporate backers. If this reporting matters to you, help keep it free for everyone.

Support VPN from $5
Your turn

Join the conversation

What do you think? Share your view below. Disagreement is welcome; personal attacks are not. Comments are moderated.

Leave a Reply