Independent journalism from St. Vincent and the GrenadinesSupport VPNNewsletterAdvertiseYouTubeContact
VINCYPOWA NEWSPower to the People

Independent journalism from St. Vincent and the Grenadines, for the Caribbean and the world.

, ,

Looking at a Festival Painted for Someone Else

VINCYPOWA News feature image for Looking at a Festival Painted for Someone Else, depicting the historic St. Vincent festival engraving.

By Lance O. Davis | VINCYPOWA News

I was born in St. Vincent, and so were my parents’ people. That is why I stopped when I found an engraving in the digital collection of the Library Company of Philadelphia. Based on a painting by Agostino Brunias, it carries the historical title A Negro Festival, drawn from Nature in the Island of St. Vincent. The print circulated in the 1790s, including in publications associated with the British Caribbean planter class.

Restored engraving after Agostino Brunias depicting a St. Vincent festival, with dancers, a drummer, a tambourine player, and a fruit vendor.
Historical engraving after Agostino Brunias. Image courtesy of the Library Company of Philadelphia. Digitally cleaned and restored.

I see people dancing, with a drummer and a woman with a tambourine at the edge of the crowd. A woman bends over a spread of fruit that includes a pineapple. Everyone is dressed with care. It looks like a party.

What Agostino Brunias Chose Not to Show

But I cannot forget who this picture was made for. The painter, Agostino Brunias, worked for wealthy colonial patrons. Versions of the engraving appeared with The History, Civil and Commercial, of the British Colonies in the West Indies by Bryan Edwards, a Jamaican slaveholder. The picture is far gentler than the island’s colonial reality. It shows no forced labor and no fear.

In 1795, St. Vincent was at war. The Garifuna leader Joseph Chatoyer, now the country’s national hero, was killed in March of that year. In 1797, the British deported thousands of Garifuna from their homeland.

So I look at two things at once. One is a picture designed for a British audience, a colonial image that could make an unjust society appear peaceful. The other is the possibility of people whose music, clothes, and dancing were expressions of their own lives.

The historian Lennox Honychurch has suggested that the gathering may portray free people of color rather than an enslaved festival. He has also cautioned that the engraving combines figures seen in scenes from other Caribbean islands. The title says St. Vincent, but we cannot assume that every figure was observed together at one event. No one can say for sure who all these people were, and I would rather put that doubt on the record than offer a neat story.

I cleaned up the scan of the engraving based on Agostino Brunias’s painting so the details could be seen: the leaves, the faces, the pineapple. This is the island I was born on, seen through someone else’s eyes. I wanted the image clear enough for us to look at properly, while remembering what the artist chose not to show.

Sources and image credit

Historical image: Library Company of Philadelphia, digital collection. Discussion of the engraving and Lennox Honychurch’s interpretation: Slavery Images. Context on the art’s plantation audience: Royal Museums Greenwich. Chatoyer and the Garifuna exile: SVG Ministry of Tourism. The historical title is reproduced for identification and does not reflect this publication’s language.

Vincypowa News is independent and self-funded. We apply the same scrutiny to every government. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it. Our standards

Get the VPN Morning Brief

The day’s most important SVG and Caribbean stories, free in your inbox before work.

Support independent journalism

Vincypowa News is self-funded, with no party, government or corporate backers. If this reporting matters to you, help keep it free for everyone.

Support VPN from $5
Your turn

Join the conversation

What do you think? Share your view below. Disagreement is welcome; personal attacks are not. Comments are moderated.

Leave a Reply