Election Petitions 2026
Petitioners close their case as Friday citizenship trial reaches its halfway mark
Three days of evidence ended in Kingstown with both sides claiming the advantage. The judge will not hear the government’s witnesses until September, pushing any ruling on the Prime Minister’s eligibility deep into the year.
The Unity Labour Party candidates seeking to overturn the elections of Prime Minister Godwin Friday and Foreign Minister Dwight Fitzgerald Bramble closed their case on Thursday, ending the first stretch of a constitutional trial that will decide whether both men were ever qualified to sit in Parliament. Three scheduled days of hearings before the High Court in Kingstown produced testimony from several witnesses and a Canadian immigration expert, and left the two Trinidadian senior counsel leading each side each professing confidence.
Lead counsel for the petitioners, former Trinidad and Tobago prime minister Stuart Young SC, told reporters the petitioners had completed their evidence, including their expert, and said he looked ahead to cross examining the government’s witnesses. “I feel good on behalf of the petitioners,” he said, adding that nothing in the proceedings had surprised him.
Lead counsel for the respondents, former Trinidad and Tobago attorney general Anand Ramlogan SC, framed the same moment differently. “We are at the halfway mark of the trial,” he said, reporting that he had cross examined both petitioners and all of their witnesses and that “several remarkable things” had emerged under questioning that his side would put to the court.
What is being challenged in the Friday citizenship trial
The two petitions, heard together, were filed in December 2025 by Carlos Williams, the ULP’s Northern Grenadines candidate, and Luke Browne, its East Kingstown candidate. They ask the court to void the elections of Friday and Bramble on the ground that each man voluntarily acquired Canadian citizenship, and is therefore caught by Section 26(1)(a) of the Constitution, which bars anyone who is, “by virtue of his own act”, under an acknowledgement of allegiance, obedience or adherence to a foreign power or state.
Neither man was born in Canada, and both have accepted that they took up Canadian citizenship as adults. The petitioners argue that Canada is a foreign state and that the acknowledgement of allegiance flowing from citizenship and the use of a Canadian passport is disqualifying, full stop. The government’s team argues the opposite: that the Constitution positively recognises Commonwealth citizens as qualified to be elected, that Canada is a Commonwealth country, and that acquiring Canadian citizenship therefore cannot strip a Vincentian-born candidate of the right to stand.
We are at the halfway mark of the trial. Anand Ramlogan SC, lead counsel for the respondents
The stakes are unusually high for a body of law rarely tested here. Friday, who has represented the Northern Grenadines since 2001 and is now Prime Minister as well as Minister of Finance, is in his sixth term. Bramble, first elected in 2020, is in his second term at East Kingstown. Both won their seats comfortably in November: Friday took 2,185 votes to Williams’ 339, while Bramble defeated Browne by 1,001 votes. The New Democratic Party swept the general election 14 to 1, the most decisive Vincentian result since 1989.
The expert, and the argument over her evidence
Central to the petitioners’ case was Sarah McKins, a Canadian immigration attorney who testified virtually and was cross examined at length by Ramlogan. Her evidence went to how a person acquires Canadian citizenship, the pivot on which Section 26(1)(a) turns, since the clause distinguishes citizenship gained passively, by birth or descent, from citizenship taken up by a deliberate adult act such as naturalisation or the swearing of an oath.
Young said the petitioners had applied to amplify the expert’s evidence, an application argued over several hours, and that the court granted it on the final morning before the rest of the day’s evidence flowed from that ruling. He acknowledged some “theatrics” in the exchanges but said the respondents were entitled to press whatever objections they wished.
A parallel move in Parliament
The court fight runs alongside a legislative one. Twice this year, on the order papers for 21 April and 2 July, the Friday government listed the Representation of the People (Amendment) Bill 2026 and the Constitution (Amendment) Bill 2026 for a first reading, both drafted to be retroactive to 1979, the year the Constitution came into force. Both bills were deferred on each occasion, and the Prime Minister had earlier promised public consultation before proceeding.
The ULP has called the bills “self-serving” and demanded their removal from the order paper until the court rules, arguing that reintroducing them during Carnival amounted to an attempt to change the rules retroactively while the petitions were live. Searchlight has reported that the promised consultations had not taken place as of the July sitting. The government has not tabled the bills for debate, and maintains that Friday never concealed his dual citizenship and that voters chose him knowing it.
Vincentian legal opinion is genuinely split. Attorney Linton Lewis, a former NDP senator and chairman now estranged from the party, has argued that a challenge to the two nominations would succeed. Law lecturer Jason Haynes has argued that a proper reading of the Constitution, with its explicit provision for Commonwealth citizens, means any such challenge should fail.
What happens next
- First week of September 2026. The respondents open their case and call their witnesses. The petitioners’ team will then cross examine them.
- November 2026. Both sides file and argue their closing legal submissions before Justice Gertel Thom, a retired Justice of Appeal sitting as an acting High Court judge.
- Judgment. A ruling is expected after submissions, with observers pointing to late in the year. Senior figures in the governing NDP have privately been mentioned as possible successors should the court find against the Prime Minister.
Whatever Justice Thom decides is likely to be appealed, given the constitutional weight of the question and the fact that it has never been settled by a Vincentian court. For now, the case has reached its interval with the petitioners’ evidence in and the government’s yet to come, and with the meaning of a single clause written in 1979 still waiting to be resolved.
Both the petitioners and the respondents are represented by senior counsel and were offered the opportunity to state their positions; the remarks quoted here were made to the media outside the High Court. Vote figures and procedural dates are drawn from court reporting by iWitness News, the St Vincent Times, Searchlight and The Vincentian, cross checked against the text of the Constitution of St Vincent and the Grenadines.





Leave a Reply