Trinidad and Tobago violates the constitutional right to privacy when it treats consensual sexual intimacy between adults of the same sex as a crime, the Privy Council ruled Tuesday, November 10. All five judges sided with activist Jason Jones, overturning a Court of Appeal ruling that had kept part of the criminal prohibition in place. The Board also dismissed the Attorney General’s cross-appeal.

Jason Jones brought the case in 2017. In a sworn statement, he described avoiding public transportation because he feared for his safety. He also described the fear that police could arrest him and bring him before a court because of his sexuality. The Attorney General did not dispute his account.
Why Jason Jones won his constitutional challenge
At issue were sections 13 and 16 of the 1986 Sexual Offences Act, covering “buggery” and “serious indecency.” The latter made an explicit exception for private, consensual acts between a man and a woman. Same-sex couples had no equivalent protection. The High Court ruled in Jones’s favor in 2018. In 2025, a Court of Appeal majority concluded that the Constitution shielded parts of the law because similar offenses had existed before 1976.
The Privy Council found that when Parliament overhauled the country’s sexual offenses laws in 1986, it made a fresh legislative choice. The Constitution’s protection for preexisting laws therefore did not shield the two provisions. Although Parliament passed the Act by a special majority, Jason Jones could still challenge whether the intrusion into his private life was justified. The judges assessed that question against conditions today. They found that the State’s appeal to tradition could not justify criminal penalties for consensual intimacy.
The ruling in favor of Jason Jones settles the constitutional question. The judges invited both sides to make written submissions on the wording of the final order. They indicated that they favored the High Court’s approach, which would exclude private, consensual adult conduct from the reach of the two offenses while preserving their other applications.
Read the Privy Council’s judgment in the Jason Jones case.
More Caribbean court coverage from VINCYPOWA News — Court overturns stay in Adriana King case as DPP signals plan to end prosecution.





Leave a Reply