Independent journalism from St. Vincent and the GrenadinesSupport VPNNewsletterAdvertiseYouTubeContact
VINCYPOWA NEWSPower to the People

Independent journalism from St. Vincent and the Grenadines, for the Caribbean and the world.

, , ,

From the Nile to the Savannah: Where Carnival Really Began in the Americas

From the Nile to the Savannah: The Real Carnival History of the Americas

Carnival history, checked against the records: not Trinidad, not New Orleans and not ancient Egypt. A 1578 royal inquiry in Spain’s colonial archive puts the first documented carnival in the Americas on Hispaniola. And St. Vincent’s own carnival riots came two years before Trinidad’s famous Canboulay.

Ask most people where carnival history begins and you will hear one of three answers: ancient Egypt, Trinidad or New Orleans. A Vincypowa News review of primary documents and published scholarship finds that all three are wrong as answers to the question of where carnival first took root in the Americas.

The earliest carnival in the Americas that survives in a written record was celebrated in Santo Domingo, on the Caribbean island of Hispaniola, now shared by the Dominican Republic and Haiti. Sworn testimony gathered there in 1578 describes masks, evening dances and street battles with oranges stretching back to about the late 1530s.

Closer to home, the story holds a surprise for Vincentians. Colonial reports show St. Vincent banned street masquerade in 1872, and that crowds rioted against the ban in 1879, two years before Trinidad’s better-known Canboulay riots of 1881.

Carnival history timeline: Rome 1140s, Santo Domingo 1530s, Pernambuco 1553, Mobile 1703, Trinidad 1783 and St. Vincent's carnival riots of 1879
Carnival history in the Americas, from the first documented celebration on Hispaniola to St. Vincent’s 1879 riots. Graphic: Vincypowa News

Carnival history does not start in ancient Egypt

The claim that carnival began on the Nile is popular but unsupported. Egypt’s goddess Isis did have a spring festival, the Navigium Isidis, or “Vessel of Isis,” celebrated across the Roman Empire every March 5. Costumed worshippers carried a model ship from her temple to the sea, and the Roman writer Apuleius described a comic, masked procession leading the way in the second century.

That looks a lot like a carnival parade. It is not the same thing. A widely repeated theory says the word “carnival” comes from carrus navalis, a “naval wagon” or float, but no ancient text ever called the festival by that name.

Greece and Rome offered closer parallels. The festivals of Dionysus gave Europe its tradition of the mask, and during Rome’s Saturnalia, masters were said to serve the people they enslaved. Historian Max Harris, in a study published in European Medieval Drama in 2006, warned that resemblance is not the same as descent. Those festivals had died out long before carnival appeared. The likeliest indirect influence, he argued, was the Roman New Year festival, the Kalends of January, which churchmen were still condemning for its masks into the twelfth century.

Carnival is a Christian feast, first named in Rome

The first firm date in carnival history comes from Rome. Between 1140 and 1143, the festival appears by name as the Ludus Carnevalarii in a record compiled by Benedict, a canon of St. Peter’s. The pope rode out to Testaccio with the city’s knights while nobles staged jousts and races.

The word itself comes from early Italian carnelevare, “to remove meat,” marking the last feast before the Lenten fast. The popular translation “farewell to the flesh” is a folk etymology with no historical basis.

The colonizers who reached the Caribbean used their own names for it. The Spanish called it carnestolendas, with orange fights, perfumed wax “eggs,” masks and dances. The Portuguese called it entrudo, a rough water fight. The French called it Mardi Gras and celebrated it with masked balls.

Hispaniola: the first documented carnival in the Americas

On April 30, 1578, Diego de Villanueva Zapata, the Spanish crown’s prosecutor in Santo Domingo, opened a formal inquiry into what he called the “ancient custom” of the colony’s highest judges throwing oranges at carnival. The file survives in the General Archive of the Indies in Seville, Spain, and was transcribed and published by historian Paola Andrea Berrío in the Colombian journal Historia y Sociedad in 2017. It is the oldest firm date in the carnival history of the Americas.

Eleven sworn witnesses described the scene:

  • The president and judges of the royal court rode the main streets on horses and mules, trading oranges, scented water and perfumed wax eggs with women at the windows.
  • Masked residents came to the royal houses by day, and masked dancers attended evening dances in the royal hall.
  • One witness said the festivities once began two months before Ash Wednesday “with many masks.”
  • The court notary had lived in the city for 40 years and named presidents going back to the late 1530s.

The answer from the Council of the Indies in Spain was a single line ordering that it not be done again. Berrío notes an important limit: this was the Spanish colonists’ own festival, and it excluded Black and Indigenous people.

The Dominican Republic officially dates its carnival even earlier, to La Vega in 1510 or 1520. That date is plausible, but the documents behind it have not been published, so Vincypowa News treats it as tradition rather than established fact.

Brazil follows close behind. An Inquisition deposition from 1593 records a sugar planter in Pernambuco serving fish on an entrudo Tuesday in 1553 and then, to the scandal of his workers, pork on Ash Wednesday.

Mobile, New Orleans and Trinidad came later

In carnival history, North America’s claims arrive more than 150 years after Santo Domingo’s. French explorers named a spot on the Mississippi “Pointe du Mardi Gras” on March 3, 1699, but recorded no celebration. Mobile, Alabama, dates its first Mardi Gras to 1703, a date that rests largely on local tradition. New Orleans’ parading tradition dates from 1857.

Trinidad’s carnival, the most influential in the Caribbean today, begins with the Spanish crown’s Cedula of Population in 1783, which drew French Catholic planters from Martinique, Guadeloupe, Grenada and St. Vincent, along with the Africans they enslaved. Historian John Cowley, author of Carnival, Canboulay and Calypso, found no concrete evidence of a regular carnival on the island before then.

After emancipation in 1838, freed Africans took carnival into the streets and made Canboulay, the “burnt cane” procession of drums and torches, their own. That is the carnival Trinidad, and much of the region, inherited.

St. Vincent’s carnival history is older than Vincy Mas

Many Vincentians date carnival to 1977, when it moved from the days before Lent to the summer as Vincy Mas. The history goes back much further.

As historian Dr. Adrian Fraser has documented, the colonial administrator, Laborde, reported that in 1872 wearing a mask in the street became a punishable offense in St. Vincent. Laborde described a long-standing practice of people in “fantastic attire” and masks parading and dancing through the streets with sticks or whips.

In February 1879, masqueraders defied the ban. On the night of Tuesday, February 11, police in Kingstown were driven back with sticks, bottles and stones. The next day the authorities swore in 121 special constables, and a crowd of 300 to 400 people pelted the administrator’s carriage. In Trinidad, authorities feared torches. In St. Vincent, they feared the mask. Vincypowa News told the full story of those nights in The Carnival Riots of 1879: When Kingstown Rose for the Right to Masquerade.

The earliest surviving image of a festival on the island is even older. A Negro Festival Drawn from Nature in the Island of St. Vincent, engraved in London in 1794 from a painting by Agostino Brunias, shows dancers moving to drums. The original belonged to Sir William Young, a St. Vincent planter and leading pro-slavery politician, and it was meant to show contented slaves. It still records a real festival form.

Correcting the record on St. Vincent’s carnival riots

The official history published by the Carnival Development Corporation correctly names February 11 and 12 as the days of the riots. But it gives a ban in 1892 and the riots in 1899, and says Trinidad’s riots followed four years later. Those years contradict each other and Trinidad’s documented riots of 1881. The administrator’s own despatch, dated February 15, 1879, settles that part of St. Vincent’s carnival history: the riots took place in 1879.

Vincypowa News has asked The National Archives in Kew, England, to identify the original 1872 and 1879 Colonial Office papers so they can be examined directly. We will report what the files show.

What carnival history tells us about who made it

Europe supplied the date on the calendar. Africans and their descendants supplied most of what makes Caribbean carnival distinct: the drum, the masquerade character, call-and-response song and the politics of the street. Jamaica’s Jonkonnu masquerade, Cuba’s African cabildos dancing on Three Kings’ Day and Trinidad’s Canboulay all grew up beside the colonists’ festival before taking it over.

That is the real line from the Nile to the Savannah. Carnival did not travel intact from ancient Egypt. It was born as a Christian feast in medieval Italy, crossed the Atlantic with Spain, reached the Americas first on Hispaniola, and was remade by the people the colonizers enslaved. Vincentians who took to the streets of Kingstown in 1879 belong to that story too.

Sources

Vincypowa News is independent and self-funded. We apply the same scrutiny to every government. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it. Our standards

Get the VPN Morning Brief

The day’s most important SVG and Caribbean stories, free in your inbox before work.

Support independent journalism

Vincypowa News is self-funded, with no party, government or corporate backers. If this reporting matters to you, help keep it free for everyone.

Support VPN from $5
Your turn

Join the conversation

What do you think? Share your view below. Disagreement is welcome; personal attacks are not. Comments are moderated.

Leave a Reply